Logging

Film: Infernal Affairs

Every memorable scene from The Departed exists in this film. The Departed is a better crafted film, more stylish, bigger, more spectacular version. But what points should we reward originality in cinema vs. craft? The brilliant set up of The Departed and the most tension filled scenes are all copied from Infernal Affairs. The only thing truly added is style and a slight twist on the ending. Does this take away from The Departed as a work? I think it does.  I think it matters what comes first.  And I think the accolades heaved upon The Departed are slightly undeserved.   I know it recognizes itself as a remake, but no one talks of the brilliance of Point of No Return or 3:10 to Yuma.  This is a reputation thing - the Academy owed Scorcese an Oscar and Monahan is considered a "hip" writer.